AoC Market Analysis: Toned 1896 Morgan Dollar in ‘5

This week, we’ve picked an interesting one.

1896 Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS65 Obverse, Photo by Phil Arnold

1896 Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS65 Obverse, Photo by Phil Arnold

This 1896 (common date) Morgan Silver Dollar is graded PCGS MS65, Green CAC. The recent PCGS holder has it pedigreed to the Aurora Borealis collection.

PCGS Price Guide for an 1896 Morgan Silver Dollar in Mint State 65 is $150. Hundreds of 1896 Morgans have sold this year for $100 to $200. So why did this coin sell for $4,465?

Well, the answer is obvious – it’s all about the toning. The pedigree doesn’t hurt either! But how did the buyer come up with that price? Is it just a magic number that popped into his or her head when they saw the coin?

Let’s dissect it a bit and see what we can come up with.

First of all, is the coin over or undergraded?

Nope. It’s right on. The reverse is marked up in the breast, otherwise the reverse could seven. By the way, the reverse has no toning. The obverse shows a pretty weak strike, normal for ’96-Ps. It even has massive striations, a planchet flaw, not from any kind of friction or bag. These striations didn’t play into the grade. The strike did. Ignoring the striations, as the graders did, and looking purely at the bag marks, the coin could ‘6+ or maybe even 7, except that a couple of the marks are unmissable. But the strike takes off a point, and the striations keep it out of a plus as the coin is not exceptional for the grade.

The toning and luster, however, are.

One of us here, in particular, likes to look at the toning just like the rest of us look at problems on coins. “How much does the toning of the coin improve or decrease the grade of the coin?” “What grade of naturally untoned coin would I prefer to have?” You can do this with problem coins, too – how much does that environmental damage impact the coin. If you can quantify it into a grade number, you may help yourself arrive at numbers when ready to buy and sell pieces from your collection.

Of course, these numbers are all completely personal. Everyone will have a different opinion. But at least, it could be a starting point.

Looking at Phil’s photographs of the coin, I’d say I’d rather have this coin than your run-of-the-mill 6, maybe even 6+. This isn’t my favorite toning. If there was a coin like this, a 5, with perfect (in my opinion), double-sided, natural toning, I might rather have it than an 8. But not this one, not for me. Not looking at these pictures.

But let’s look at Patrick’s shot of the coin. It shows the luster much better. (I’m not trying to compare Patrick and Phil’s photography – they do different things, and that’s how it should be. In this case, Phil’s photo shows more detail, and Patrick’s shows a bit better what the coin looks like in-hand.) This coin has incredible, luminous luster. Looking at the Legend photo, I’d rather have this coin than a 7. I’m not huge on the striations, and I don’t have to have this kind of toning in my collection, and it’s not double-sided. But for me, at least, it takes it into 6+ or possibly 7 territory.

1896 Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS65 CAC Obverse, Photo by Patrick Braswell

1896 Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS65 CAC Obverse, Photo by Patrick Braswell

For the auction winner and underbidder, this coin was apparently a 7+. (If they applied this kind of logic to their preparatory thinking. Of course, it could just be a “had to have it, money is no object” moment, too.) Looking at some of the recent auction results for ‘7 and 67+ coins, we see they range from a couple grand up to almost 8 territory. And seeing as there hasn’t been an 8 to come to auction for a while, and this wild toning, it certainly was the coin a couple of people had to have.

Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

How Much Are My Coins Worth?com
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.

Cookie Policy for How Much Are My Coins Worth

This is the Cookie Policy for How Much Are My Coins Worth, accessible from https://howmucharemycoinsworth.com

What Are Cookies

As is common practice with almost all professional websites this site uses cookies, which are tiny files that are downloaded to your computer, to improve your experience. This page describes what information they gather, how we use it and why we sometimes need to store these cookies. We will also share how you can prevent these cookies from being stored however this may downgrade or 'break' certain elements of the sites functionality.

For more general information on cookies see the Wikipedia article on HTTP Cookies.

How We Use Cookies

We use cookies for a variety of reasons detailed below. Unfortunately in most cases there are no industry standard options for disabling cookies without completely disabling the functionality and features they add to this site. It is recommended that you leave on all cookies if you are not sure whether you need them or not in case they are used to provide a service that you use.

Disabling Cookies

You can prevent the setting of cookies by adjusting the settings on your browser (see your browser Help for how to do this). Be aware that disabling cookies will affect the functionality of this and many other websites that you visit. Disabling cookies will usually result in also disabling certain functionality and features of the this site. Therefore it is recommended that you do not disable cookies.

The Cookies We Set

  • Account related cookies

    If you create an account with us then we will use cookies for the management of the signup process and general administration. These cookies will usually be deleted when you log out however in some cases they may remain afterwards to remember your site preferences when logged out.

  • Login related cookies

    We use cookies when you are logged in so that we can remember this fact. This prevents you from having to log in every single time you visit a new page. These cookies are typically removed or cleared when you log out to ensure that you can only access restricted features and areas when logged in.

  • Email newsletters related cookies

    This site offers newsletter or email subscription services and cookies may be used to remember if you are already registered and whether to show certain notifications which might only be valid to subscribed/unsubscribed users.

  • Orders processing related cookies

    This site offers e-commerce or payment facilities and some cookies are essential to ensure that your order is remembered between pages so that we can process it properly.

  • Surveys related cookies

    From time to time we offer user surveys and questionnaires to provide you with interesting insights, helpful tools, or to understand our user base more accurately. These surveys may use cookies to remember who has already taken part in a survey or to provide you with accurate results after you change pages.

  • Forms related cookies

    When you submit data to through a form such as those found on contact pages or comment forms cookies may be set to remember your user details for future correspondence.

  • Site preferences cookies

    In order to provide you with a great experience on this site we provide the functionality to set your preferences for how this site runs when you use it. In order to remember your preferences we need to set cookies so that this information can be called whenever you interact with a page is affected by your preferences.

Third Party Cookies

In some special cases we also use cookies provided by trusted third parties. The following section details which third party cookies you might encounter through this site.

  • This site uses Google Analytics which is one of the most widespread and trusted analytics solution on the web for helping us to understand how you use the site and ways that we can improve your experience. These cookies may track things such as how long you spend on the site and the pages that you visit so we can continue to produce engaging content.

    For more information on Google Analytics cookies, see the official Google Analytics page.

  • From time to time we test new features and make subtle changes to the way that the site is delivered. When we are still testing new features these cookies may be used to ensure that you receive a consistent experience whilst on the site whilst ensuring we understand which optimisations our users appreciate the most.
  • As we sell products it's important for us to understand statistics about how many of the visitors to our site actually make a purchase and as such this is the kind of data that these cookies will track. This is important to you as it means that we can accurately make business predictions that allow us to monitor our advertising and product costs to ensure the best possible price.
  • We use adverts to offset the costs of running this site and provide funding for further development. The behavioural advertising cookies used by this site are designed to ensure that we provide you with the most relevant adverts where possible by anonymously tracking your interests and presenting similar things that may be of interest.
  • Several partners advertise on our behalf and affiliate tracking cookies simply allow us to see if our customers have come to the site through one of our partner sites so that we can credit them appropriately and where applicable allow our affiliate partners to provide any bonus that they may provide you for making a purchase.
  • We also use social media buttons and/or plugins on this site that allow you to connect with your social network in various ways. For these to work the following social media sites including; {List the social networks whose features you have integrated with your site?:12}, will set cookies through our site which may be used to enhance your profile on their site or contribute to the data they hold for various purposes outlined in their respective privacy policies.

More Information

Hopefully that has clarified things for you and as was previously mentioned if there is something that you aren't sure whether you need or not it's usually safer to leave cookies enabled in case it does interact with one of the features you use on our site. This Cookies Policy was created with the help of the CookiePolicyGenerator.com

However if you are still looking for more information then you can contact us through one of our preferred contact methods:

  • Email: help@howmucharemycoinsworth.com
Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On FacebookVisit Us On InstagramVisit Us On PinterestCheck Our Feed